My Favorite Coffee Cake

On Christmas morning I love having something sweet to eat and also fill the house with that homemade smell. And of course, the boys love to eat it and Mo helps by getting in the way with the cooking.

I came across a great recipe for a homemade coffee cake on another mom’s blog. It’s one of those foods that kind of looks fancy and hard to make (your guests will be impressed), but it’s actually super easy. Helllllooooo…..I make it all the time.

Not only are there step by step directions, but also easy to follow pictures (for those of us that never actually READ the instructions). She assured all the readers that it was EASY (moms NEVER lie on a blog, right?).  Thank goodness she was right. It looked and tasted as if I’d been up since sunrise, but I had actually prepared it the night before then popped it in the over an hour before the guests arrived.


2 cups Bisquick (don’t have any? make your own and thank me later)

1/4 cup butter, cubed and COLD

3 ounces cream cheese, cubed — the brick-style, not the kind in a tub

1/3 cup milk


about 2/3 cup fruit preserves


2 Tb milk

1/2 cup powdered sugar


– pastry knife

– bowl with rounded bottom

– parchment paper and wax paper

– rolling pin

– cookie sheet

Pre-heat oven to 375° F.

Place Bisquick, butter and cream cheese in a round-bottomed bowl. Using a pastry knife, cut the mix together. Don’t have a pastry knife? Get a regular knife in each hand and go at it.

Drizzle the milk over the mix and stir until almost combined. Dump it out onto wax paper and press into a log shape. Do this quickly so the heat of your hands does not melt the butter. Place another sheet of wax paper on top and roll it out until it is an oblong shape about 12 inches long. In the US your roll of wax paper is probably 12 inches, so you can use that as your guide.


Don’t have wax paper? You can use saran wrap instead, but don’t blame me if it all ends up a ball. I can never use that stuff…


Remove the top sheet of wax paper. Place a sheet of parchment paper on the cookie sheet, turn the dough out into the center, and remove the second sheet of wax paper. Score two lines down the center of the dough two inches apart to use as a guide. Cut flaps in the dough at an angle.

Don’t have parchment paper? you can just smear a little butter on the cookie sheet instead, but it will be a little harder to get the pastry transferred onto the serving plate.

Now you’ll add the filling. I used two kinds of preserves — apricot and cherry — but using one also works well. Leave about an inch at either end with no preserves.


Start closing up the pastry by folding in one end so that the preserves don’t melt out of the pastry when cooking. Fold each set of flaps to the middle being sure to squeeze them together so that they don’t open up in the heat. Make another fold at the end to close it off.


Bake for 25 minutes or until golden brown. Cool for 30 minutes.

Add 2 tablespoons milk to 1/2 cup powdered sugar. Whisk until the lumps are gone. Transfer pastry to serving platter and drizzle this glaze over top. Let it set before serving.


Thanks Erica for sharing your MIL’s coffee cake recipe. I love it and make it at least twice a year.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...